Bay Shore Place

Bay Shore Place

Sold $990,000s – $1.8M · Around $2,200/mo

Bay Shore Place is a 1994 condominium building at 4255 Gulf Shore Boulevard North, in Park Shore. The building holds 103 homes, every one of them a condominium, sharing a single street address, and nothing has gone up on the site since.

The building is not on the beach: its land stops short of the water. The ground that carries on west to the sand belongs to Park Shore Towers, at 4251, which shares the entire western edge. So the address is a place in the Gulf Shore Boulevard corridor, a few hundred feet back from the Gulf.

How close is the water?

About 700 feet. That's the distance west from the building to the shoreline, across land the condominium doesn't own. Gulf Shore Boulevard North, a public City of Naples street, runs about 330 feet to the east. There's a public beach access half a mile north, at 4999 Gulf Shore Boulevard North. The Village Shops on Venetian Bay, which everyone local calls Venetian Village, are a quarter of a mile away at 4200 Gulf Shore Boulevard North.

What are the homes like?

Six floor areas cover all 103 homes, and four of them repeat in bulk: about 1,457 square feet on 28 homes, about 1,536 on another 28, about 1,649 on 28 more, and about 1,692 on 15. Four bigger homes sit above those, two at about 2,281 square feet and two at about 2,360. So almost the whole building sits in a narrow band under 1,700 square feet, and only four homes of the 103 clear 2,000.

Seven front doors open onto most levels and five onto the top one, fifteen levels of homes in all. The numbering skips 13 altogether. A listing's square footage tends to sit a little above the heated area recorded for the same home, because the two are measured differently.

What does it cost to own here?

Budget around $2,200 a month. That figure leans high on purpose, which makes it safe to plan against and wrong as a picture of what a single owner is billed.

Homes have sold here from the $990,000s to around $1.8 million. Four sales out of 103 stand behind that span, all of them smaller repeating plans, so it says nothing about the four largest homes in the building.

What should you read before you make an offer?

Before the floor plan, the structure. A condominium tower reaching thirty years owes Florida a structural examination, signed off by a licensed architect or engineer. A city can pull that date forward to twenty-five where salt water is close by. This one was finished in 1994, so both marks are behind it. Florida also makes an association price its major structural work in advance, and that price sets the minimum it has to put aside each year.

A deadline in the past tells you nothing about the finding. Read the engineer's write-up and the reserve figures together, because between them they settle whether the assessment stays put or a repair bill follows. Permits and inspections here run through the City of Naples rather than Collier County, since the site sits inside the city. The three documents that answer it:

  • The engineer's findings on the structure, and any repairs called for.
  • The reserve study, and how much of what it asks for is banked.
  • The recorded declaration with its amendments, which is where the rules for living here are set.

Is the private beach park down the road part of this?

No. The park at 4061 Gulf Shore Boulevard North is a fifth of a mile south. It belongs to the Park Shore Association, a voluntary body formed in 1971 that sits outside this condominium altogether. It charges nothing to an owner at 4255, and it maintains nothing on the site.

Its published park rules put the entrance plainly: "Admittance by vehicle, bike, or on foot requires your active Park Shore Association membership card. Hours of operation are from dawn to dusk."

Membership is something a person applies for, and the board says yes or no. An application goes in online, with a one-time initiation charge and a whole year of dues attached. The dues run to the calendar year, and both amounts are reset annually by the board, which is why only the association can quote you a figure. The bylaws are blunt on the point: "Dues are not refunded when the property is sold before the end of a membership year." So the park is a separate decision with a separate cost, taken after the closing rather than inherited at it.

South of the tower there's a pool, with two small structures beside it, and a guest room inside the building that owners can use. The 2.29 acres underneath belong to the condominium itself.

Quick Facts

Costs
Home Prices
Sold $990,000s – $1.8M
Monthly Fees
Around $2,200/mo
Community
Residences
103 condominiums in one building
Location
4255 Gulf Shore Blvd N, Park Shore
Established
1994
Home Sizes
1,450–2,400 sq ft

Properties for Sale

Market Snapshot

The months supply of homes for sale in Bay Shore Place, Park Shore, Naples was 1 month in September 2026, down 50% from 2 months in September 2025, according to NABOR MLS data through September 2026. This figure was also down from 2 months in August 2026. The number of homes for sale in Bay Shore Place was 1 in September 2026, consistent with the 1 home for sale in August 2026, but down from 2 homes for sale in September 2025. Condo sales activity remained limited. There were no condo sales in September 2026, nor in September 2025. For context, there was 1 condo sale in August 2026 and 1 condo sale in May 2026. Pending condo sales also saw no activity in September 2026, August 2026, or September 2025. The last pending condo sale was in July 2026, with 1 reported. Price metrics in Bay Shore Place saw fluctuations based on very few transactions. The median closed price for condos was $995,000 in August 2026, based on a single sale. The median price per square foot for condos was $683 in August 2026. These figures compare to a median closed price of $1,750,000 and a median price per square foot of $1,143 for condos in May 2026, also each based on a single transaction. There were no reported price metrics for September 2026 due to the absence of sales.

October 2026 · Last updated Oct 2, 2026

Pricing

Track how home values are trending in Bay Shore Place. Median sale prices and price-per-square-foot data help buyers and sellers gauge current market positioning.

Median Closed Price

$995,000 as of August 2026.

Tap the chart to see monthly values
$1.1M$2.4M$3.7MFeb 2023Dec 2023May 2025Aug 2026
View monthly data
MonthMedian Closed Price
February 2023$3,800,000
March 2023$1,950,000
July 2023$1,175,000
December 2023$3,400,000
January 2024$1,750,000
May 2025$1,350,000
November 2025$1,750,000
May 2026$1,750,000
August 2026$995,000

Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR®) MLS, via InfoSparks. Data through August 2026. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

$683 as of August 2026.

Tap the chart to see monthly values
$717$1K$2KFeb 2023Dec 2023May 2025Aug 2026
View monthly data
MonthMedian Prices per Sq ft
February 2023$1,434
March 2023$1,183
July 2023$780
December 2023$1,636
January 2024$1,143
May 2025$832
November 2025$1,066
May 2026$1,143
August 2026$683

Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR®) MLS, via InfoSparks. Data through August 2026. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Inventory

See how many homes are available in Bay Shore Place and how quickly inventory is moving. Months of supply indicates whether conditions favor buyers or sellers.

Homes For Sale

1 as of September 2026.

Tap the chart to see monthly values
024Oct 2023Oct 2024Sep 2025Sep 2026
View monthly data
MonthHomes For Sale
October 20250
November 20252
December 20254
January 20263
February 20263
March 20263
April 20263
May 20261
June 20262
July 20262
August 20262
September 20261

Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR®) MLS, via InfoSparks. Data through September 2026. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

1 as of September 2026.

Tap the chart to see monthly values
0.72.33.9Jan 2023Dec 2023Dec 2024Sep 2026
View monthly data
MonthMonths Supply
December 20243
November 20252
December 20254
January 20263
February 20263
March 20263
April 20263
May 20261
June 20262
July 20262
August 20262
September 20261

Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR®) MLS, via InfoSparks. Data through September 2026. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Activity

Monitor real estate transaction volume in Bay Shore Place. Pending and closed sales reflect the pace of buyer demand and overall market momentum.

Pending Sales

0 as of September 2026.

Tap the chart to see monthly values
012Oct 2023Oct 2024Sep 2025Sep 2026
View monthly data
MonthPending Sales
October 20250
November 20251
December 20250
January 20261
February 20260
March 20260
April 20260
May 20260
June 20260
July 20261
August 20260
September 20260

Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR®) MLS, via InfoSparks. Data through September 2026. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

0 as of September 2026.

Tap the chart to see monthly values
011Oct 2023Oct 2024Sep 2025Sep 2026
View monthly data
MonthTotal Sales
October 20250
November 20251
December 20250
January 20260
February 20260
March 20260
April 20260
May 20261
June 20260
July 20260
August 20261
September 20260

Source: Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR®) MLS, via InfoSparks. Data through September 2026. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Loading map…